S1·E12 – Episode 12

Callie worries about Jimmy and admits to Garrett that she's afraid of the dark and needs his help to find Jimmy. They see where he crashed and discover that his shoulder is hurt. Garrett is upset because now Jimmy won't be able to play in the Big Newport Game. Mila and Sydney ride home together and discuss the events of the night. Later, Garrett and Mila have another swimming lesson.

Cast

Sarah Michelle Gellar

Sydney Orion Rutledge

Shane McDermott

Garrett Booth

Brittany Daniel

Mila Rosnovsky

Eddie Robinson

Neil Atwater

Stacey Moseley

Callie Walker

Tom Carroll

J.T. Adams

Kirsten Mahon

Sandy Swan

Carisa Dahlbo

Glory Booth

Alessandro Tanaka

Bobby 'Saja' Decastro

Devin Doherty

Jimmy Clayton